Source: qa/presentation-r9-request.md
# Round 9 presentation re-review request Reviewer requested: Argon2 (via lmctl), independently of the author and implementation helpers. Scope: Fable's five ranked recommendations in presentation-review-Fable.md §3. Author worktree: /home/mma/worktrees/neov2-r8. Database: neov2/db/round9.sqlite. Local pages: neov2/site/explore; HTTP http://127.0.0.1:8878/explore/. Targets: §1983 and RICO outline/grid pairs, their case and element pages, plus site-wide source/counter/link checks. All 15 laws have both views. RICO's 19 top-level elements are split into panels of six columns in claim order; case rows repeat across panels, and no element or matching block is dropped. Author evidence (not independent approval): - 36 presentation/site tests and 36 loader/store tests passed. - Ruff and Pyright passed for presentation implementation; deploy guard tests passed. - qa/presentation-r9-check.py uses independent SQL and parsed HTML (no renderer import): 717 pages, 8,266 quotations, 1,078 route counters, 2,056 grid blocks, 15 full statutes and 309 highlighted spans checked, plus all internal links/fragments. - Actual Chrome DOM checks: 12 views at 390/1365px; exact quote text and no document overflow. Full statutes/highlight offsets and desktop table widths checked for §1983, RICO and Sherman. - Source corpus is read-only; the snapshot uses current human-agent case-instance annotations, omitting retained history/rejected records and machine proposals. - Review badges show explicit report, author and freshness. Historical PASS is not current legal approval; unknown freshness stays unreviewed for current counts. Please report blockers and remaining limitations, then independently recheck fixes. The author does not sign off this review. Legal case correctness is outside this presentation fidelity/usability review. Published to https://v2.neochart.com/explore/. All 1,212 combined sitemap URLs returned HTTP 200; representative pages and robots match the local output. The finalized DB snapshot is built from pushed source revision e3efe9e. Compact author evidence is presentation-r9-check.json. ## Independent review received Argon2 completed the requested review in commit d737099: PASS on all five ranked requirements and on source/count fidelity, with zero blockers. See presentation-r9-Argon2.md and its independently written script. The review includes 26 browser views and 87 tests. Optional catalogue grouping is deferred as presentation polish. This is not a legal correctness verdict.